A Meaningful Way for CCL Attorneys to Get Involved

The Illinois State Bar Association (ISBA) is currently seeking volunteer investigators for the 2026 judicial retention cycle. This presents an excellent opportunity for newer attorneys connected with the Chicago Council of Lawyers to gain hands-on experience in the judicial evaluation process.

For attorneys who are relatively new to practice or new to CCL, serving as a judicial investigator is a substantive and impactful way to become engaged in bar activities. Volunteers will:

  • Participate in the judicial evaluation process
  • Develop investigative and analytical skills
  • Engage with leaders across multiple bar associations
  • Gain deeper insight into judicial performance standards
  • Contribute to maintaining public confidence in the courts

This type of professional service strengthens both your practice and the broader legal system.

About the 2026 Judicial Retention Cycle

Interviews for the 2026 retention class are anticipated to begin on April 20, with assignments ideally confirmed by March 31, 2026. The initial focus is on jurists seeking retention for the first time. After all of these assignments are made, we would then concentrate on the rest of the Class.

The interview schedule will be concentrated and efficient:

  • Mondays through Thursdays (no Fridays)
  • Primarily scheduled during the noon hour
  • Target completion of initial interviews by May 20, 2026

Judges may be invited to appear before Alliance member bars based on the following five-point criteria:

  1. Seeking retention for the first time;
  2. Did not participate in the last evaluation (election or retention);
  3. Was rated unfavorably by any Alliance bar;
  4. Was controversial within the last six years;
  5. If the investigation uncovers something that the judge needs to address
Conflict of Interest Guidelines

To preserve the integrity of the evaluation process, investigators may not:

  • Investigate or interview a judge whose retention campaign they have supported
  • Participate if they, or their firm, have an active case before that judge

If you have information that would assist an assigned investigator, you are encouraged to share it and provide contact information.

A Timely Opportunity to Serve

Assignments are time-sensitive, and volunteers are encouraged to step forward promptly.

If you are interested in participating, please contact ISBA directly regarding available assignments.

Alliance of Bar Associations For Judicial Screening – 2026 Retention Class

  • 1 – 35: These jurists are seeking retention for the first time.
  • 26 – 67: These jurists have been through retention before.
1 Julie Bess Aimen 36 John Michael Allegretti
2 Erin Haggerty Antonietti 37 Edward A. Arce
3 Laura Ayala-Gonzalez 38 Andrea M. Buford
4 Lynn Weaver Boyle 39 Thomas J. Byrne
5 Krista D. Butler 40 Thomas J. Carroll
6 Thomas M. Cushing 41 Patrick Kevin Coughlin
7 Maire Aileen Dempsey 42 Megan Elizabeth Goldish
8 Sondra Nicole Denmark 43 Anjana Hansen
9 Jamie Guerra Dickler 44 Kerry M. Kennedy
10 Patricia M. Fallon 45 Diana L. Kenworthy
11 Michael A. Forti 46 Maureen Ward Kirby
12 Jonathan Clark Green 47 Daniel J. Kubasiak
13 Sheree Desiree Henry 48 Robert D. Kuzas
14 Bertina E. Lampkin 49 Anthony C. Kyriakopoulos
15 Daniel Edward Maloney 50 Pamela Elizabeth Loza
16 Mary Catherine Marubio 51 John J. Mahoney
17 Celestia L. Mays 52 Maritza Martinez
18 Kelly Marie McCarthy 53 Terrence J. McGuire
19 Regina Ann Mescall 54 Caroline Kate Moreland
20 Bridget Ann Mitchell 55 Lewis Nixon
21 Teresa Molina 56 James Paul Pieczonka
22 John G. Mulroe 57 Joan E. Powell
23 Lorraine Mary Murphy 58 Judith C. Rice
24 Eileen Marie O’Connor 59 Kristal Rivers
25 Nichole C. Patton 60 Abbey Fishman Romanek
26 Jill Rose Quinn 61 Diana Rosario
27 Pamela Reaves-Harris 62 Kristyna Colleen Ryan
28 Tiesha L. Smith 63 Patricia O’Brien Sheahan
29 Levander Smith, Jr. 64 Shelley Lynn Sutker-Dermer
30 Christ Stacey 65 Kenneth J. Wadas
31 Perla Tirado 66 Ursula Walowski
32 Gerardo Tristan, Jr. 67 Steven G. Watkins
33 Elizabeth Anne Walsh    
34 Tyria B. Walton    
35 Maura McMahon Zeller    

If you are familiar with any of these judges and can speak on their suitability to remain on the bench, please advise…providing contact information for the investigator.)

Updated list as of March 2nd, 2026

Investigators are needed for the following retention judges who will be interviewed:

# Name Details
1 Laura Ayala-Gonzalez Leighton Criminal Courthouse (#303)
2 Maire A. Dempsey Law Division (#2209)
3 Patricia M. Fallon Domestic Relations (CL12)
4 Michael A. Forti Domestic Relations (#3004)
5 Jonathan Clark Green Law Division (#1906)
6 Sheree D. Henry Maywood
7 Daniel E. Maloney Markham
8 Mary C. Marubio PJ – Skokie
9 Maura McMahon Zeller Domestic Relations (#1506)
10 Bridget A. Mitchell Law Division (#1606)
11 John G. Mulroe Juvenile Justice Div.
12 Lorraine M. Murphy Skokie
13 Eileen M. O’Connor Law Division (#2501)
14 Pamela Reaves-Harris Housing (#1111)
15 Tiesha L. Smith Juvenile Justice Div.
16 Christ Stacey Civil Jury
17 Elizabeth A. Walsh Law Division (#2205)
18 Tyria B. Walton Felony Criminal in Maywood