How are judges and judicial candidates evaluated before their names appear on the ballot?
In this panel discussion, representatives from the Chicago Council of Lawyers, Chicago Bar Association, Illinois State Bar Association, and Injustice Watch offer a behind-the-scenes look at the judicial evaluation process in Cook County and the information available to help voters make informed decisions.
The conversation explores the criteria used to evaluate judges and judicial candidates, how investigations are conducted, how appeals work, and how evaluation results are ultimately shared with the public. Panelists also compare the bar associations’ evaluation processes with Injustice Watch’s journalistic approach to researching judges and discuss ongoing efforts to make judicial information more accessible and understandable.
The discussion was moderated by Brian Boyle, Chair of the Administration of Justice Subcommittee of the Public Affairs Committee, and featured:
- Michael Shapiro, Chair, Chicago Bar Association Judicial Evaluation Committee
- John Bailen, Co-Chair, ISBA Standing Committee on Judicial Evaluations – Cook County
- Maya Dukmasova, Injustice Watch
- David Melton, Executive Director, Chicago Council of Lawyers
Judicial evaluations are an important resource for voters navigating Cook County judicial elections, where ballots can include a large number of judicial candidates and retention questions.
Visit our Judicial Evaluations page to learn more.








